Utilizing the capacities of the notary in managing the pre-sale process in the light of the theory of "contracting project management" with emphasis on Agency Problem
Volume 29, Issue 22, February 2023, Pages 288-257
https://doi.org/10.22067/economlaw.2023.75613.1155
Nasrin Tabatabai Hesari, Soroush Safizade
Abstract The expansion of urbanization,raised raised the issue of housing and construction development as a necessity.In this regard, the legislator, by creating a contract called pre-sale of buildings, in addition to facilitating access to affordable housing, helped finance construction projects. However, the pre-sale contract is like a sapling that simply plants it without taking measures for its care and management, dries it up. the lack of a management-monitoring model in the building pre-sale process has been a serious issue in the pre seller-pre buyer relationship which has created many problems. Therefore, the question is how to achieve a legal mechanism for efficient management of the pre-sale process.
To answer this question, this article, based on the method of desk research and referring to documents in collecting information, along with descriptive-analytical researching method, first of all, considered the issue of Payment supervision and arbitration in disputes as the most challenging issues in buyer-seller relations. And in the framework of the study of the role of the notary in the pre-sale process in foreign law and the opinions of experts in the field of the capacities of the notary system, has presented a model to answer this question based on the rationale of the agency issue in economics and using the theory of contracting project management centered on the role of the notary.
Criteria for determining the investment contract in foreign investment arbitration
Volume 28, Issue 19, February 2022, Pages 292-317
https://doi.org/10.22067/lowecon.2022.41779
, Rahim Baghban, , Hadise Yekta
Abstract Sources and basics of foreign investment law are mostly seen in bilateral and multilateral treaties and international arbitration procedures. Thereupon, some questions arise: What is the notion of foreign investment and what are its criteria? What contracts could be considered as investment? And, what about the sale contracts? For discovering the criteria of investments, at first is reffered to the criteria mentioned in Washington convention, and then to the criteria in important arbitrations on foreign investments.
Library method was used in this research, while, by referring to theoretical discussions, arbitrational procedures for discovering the methods and criteria for investment contracts were considered.
The results indicated that three main criteria - participation, specified period of time, and risk - make the nucleus of a foreign investment, in addition to which the objectives mentioned in Article 25 of ICSID Convention and bilateral investment treaties should be considered. Regarding sale contracts, arbitration procedures say that the simple contracts aren’t in conformity with the objectives of Washington Convention. But this approach can’t be extended to all the sale contracts
Transparency Principle in Iran’s Public Procurement in the Light of WTO and EU Rules
Volume 27, Issue 18, June 2021, Pages 295-324
https://doi.org/10.22067/lowecon.2021.49340.0
Mostafa Rezaei, Assadalloh Yavari
Abstract
Extended Abstract
Introduction
Public Procurement involves a large amount of government economic activity, and because they are financed from the public budget, the principle of transparency must rule to them. Transparency is an important element in public procurement policy and law. Particularly given the socially significant nature of the system needed for the proper use of public money by all public institutions and commercial companies, the basic principles governing such spending should be well defined, and the most important of these principles is transparency. In all aspects of public procurement the public sector can influence the market structure, affect the competitive process between the market participants, and affect significantly the economic behavior of the participants in procurement processes. As a rule, contracting authorities rely on the competitive environment in public procurement to achieve the most efficient use of their budgets. They are interested in buying goods and services at low prices and of high quality, since their resources are usually more constrained than the needs to be met. In a market economy, an effective competitive process can lead to lower prices or higher quality, or more innovation in the goods or services offered. So transparency promotes competition, guarantees equality and equal treatment prevents corruption and achieves legal certainty. Therefore, one of the most important reasons for legislation in this area is transparency. In general, transparency in public procurement includes six rules: 1. Advertising contracts throughout the country, 2. Establishing competition among tenderer’, 3. Excluding tenderer from participating in the tender only for legal reasons, 4. Observance of time periods in different stages of the tender to ensure the presence of all companies in the tender, 5. Awarding the contract based on the results of the competition based on the criteria mentioned in the law and contract notice, and 6. Informing the decisions about the tender to the tenderer. However, despite the fact those more than two decades, enacting of the public procurement law in Iran, an analysis of this law and its regulations in the light of the rules of the World Trade Organization and the European Union show that public procurement in Iran has many weaknesses in terms of transparency.
Theoretical framework
This study first of all analyzes the relationship between the transparency principle and other principles of public procurement like equal treatment, competition and integrity. Then, the relationship between the transparency principle and confidentiality and protection of trade secrets is discussed. Finally, we focus on elements of transparency in public procurement like a publication of laws and regulations, documentation, a publication of contract notice and contract award notice, access to all information and documents about the process of procurement and access to verdicts of the judicial and quasi-judicial authorities.
Methodology
This study attempts to answer the main questions of this research based on the descriptive-analytical method by criticizing and analyzing laws and regulations regarding public procurement with a comparative study of European Union and WTO law.
Results & Discussion
Analysis of laws and regulations regarding public procurement regulations in the light of the rules of the WTO and the European Union show that public procurement in Iran has many weaknesses in terms of transparency, including the lack of obligation to announce cost in the contract notice, lack of clear criteria on the proliferation of newspapers, lack of obligation to inform qualitative selection, the non-publication of regarding regulations and verdicts of judicial and quasi-judicial authorities and lack of contract award notices. So these elements of transparency there aren’t in public procurement law and its regulation of Iran and these rules should be amended. This situation provides grounds for increasing corruption in public procurements and hurts to integrity of public procurements. In addition to, rights of tenderer might be violated in this circumstance. Therefore, in addition to documenting and protection of tenders’ information, it is necessary to inform the public and access information. In fact, the purpose of transparency and documentation is to make people aware of the events so that they can hold officials and executive bodies accountable based on this awareness. Also, information about tenders is important in terms of tenderers' rights in order to ensure the integrity of the procurement process; otherwise they can use this information to claim the right.
So, to make transparent of public procurement process, it is necessary to document and inform this process, publish all laws and regulation, publish contract notice and contract notice and all information and documents about the process of procurement and verdicts of the judicial and quasi-judicial authorities is accessible. It should also be noted that transparency governs all stages of the public procurement process and that information about that must be equally available at all times.
Conclusions & Suggestions
According to Findings of this research is necessary to codify and amend the relevant laws and regulations: contracting authorities are required to announce the cost of the transaction in the contract notice; Instead of publishing public procurement in newspapers, they should all be published in a single official system or journal; Qualitative selection criteria should be announced in the contract notice; The verdicts of the judicial and quasi-judicial authorities should be published in this regard and the contract authorities should be required to publish the contract award notices.
the penalty clause in monetary obligations by analyzing the procedural unity verdict no. 805 of the Supreme Court
Volume 29, Issue 21, August 2022, Pages 303-340
https://doi.org/10.22067/economlaw.2022.74203.1122
Sayed Mohammad Hassan Malaekehpour Shoushtari, Mohsen Alijani
Abstract
Although the provision of the penalty clause in monetary obligations is common, its promotion has not made its nature and rules acceptable to lawyers without any difference. According to the essence of these obligations, the root of the disputes goes back to the nature of money and the sanctity of loan usury. While the need for new banking has led the legislature to allow for claiming the excess of the amounts paid in the usury-free banking law under certain conditions, disputes over the permission to the provision of such conditions have persisted in other cases. The disagreements have caused the divergence of courts so that the Supreme Court, in line with its duties, issued the procedural unity verdict no. 805. The present study used a descriptive-analytical research method to examine the penalty clause in monetary obligations by analyzing the procedural unity verdict no. 805 of the Supreme Court and relying on judicial procedure. The results show that the penalty clause is valid even if it is higher than the inflation rate.
Territorial principle in protection of trademarks: Ensuring social goals and dealing with intellectual property as an asset
Volume 28, Issue 20, March 2022, Pages 307-340
https://doi.org/10.22067/economlaw.2022.41913
Maryam GHorbanifar,, , Hossein Kaviar
Abstract
The Role of International Law Rules in Interpretation of the WTO Agreements
Volume 29, Issue 22, February 2023, Pages 319-289
https://doi.org/10.22067/economlaw.2023.78102.1204
Asma Salari, Sasan Seyrafi
Abstract Implementation of a legal rule requires its interpretation. According to the documents of the World Trade Organization, this should be done based on the customary rules of interpretation in international law. Among the effective components in the interpretation of the organization's agreements are other rules of international law provided that they are relevant and applicable to the relations of the members of the treaty under interpretation. The components of this component are analyzed by examining the opinions of the organization's dispute resolution panel and the opinions of legal scholars in order to answer the important question of whether other rules of international law are actually applied in the interpretation of the organization's documents with the mentioned conditions.
The sources of this research are library and include the reports of jurists, opinions of international authorities and documents of international law, and the research method is descriptive-analytical.
The results of this study show that the Dispute Settlement Body of the organization, mainly with extreme reliance on the text and wording of the rule under interpretation, as well as a narrow understanding of the word "members", are resistant to the effectiveness of other related international law rules that can be applied among members.
Methods of Evaluating the Damages under Iranian and English Legal Systems and International Instruments
Volume 27, Issue 18, June 2021, Pages 325-385
https://doi.org/10.22067/lowecon.2021.67734.1000
Ali Shahabi, Seyyed Hossein Safaei, Behrooz Akhlaghi, mansour amini
Abstract Extended Abstract
Abstract:
Minimal contemplation of damages under Iranian legal and contractual liability systems is the reason leaves the constant temptation of a legal study (compared to other legal systems and the common experiences especially formed in the field of international trade). Consequently, review of the methods for evaluation of damages and reconsideration of the notions brought in modern world (with a glance at the economic requirements of the developing countries such as Iran) seems inevitable.
Having studied the methods of evaluating the damages caused by non-performance of the obligations in English legal system (as well as exploring the latest studies in this field) and also a number of most reputable international legal instruments such as CISG, Undroit, PECL and DCFR, we tried to support an interpret under Iranian law which goes beyond the current contemplations regarding the damages.
Analyzing the economic outcomes of Restitution, Expectation and Reliance methods as well as more recent theories such as Incomplete Contracts and Efficient Breach (besides the studies based on economic analysis of law during the years of 20th century), with due regard to the necessities of the local market and during the short term at least, we can rely on a justifiable basis like Expectation.
Extended Abstract
Introduction:
Minimal contemplation of the institution of damages under Iranian legal and contractual liability systems is the reason leaves the constant temptation of a legal study (compared to other legal systems and the common experiences especially formed in the field of international trade). Consequently, review of the methods for evaluation of damages and reconsideration of the notions brought in modern world (with a glance at the economic requirements of the progressive countries such as Iran) seems inevitable.
Theoretical Framework:
This study attempts to reconsider, at the very first point, the concept of “actual harm” under the Iranian legal system (as well as the contractual liability system) which leaves a major impact on our economic ambiance. We, as the Iranian lawyers, are acquainted with the phrase “there remain the possibility for the actual harms only to be compensated” (or claimed to be compensated). In light of the modern world progresses (as well as the theories rendered during the same) and the complexities of the relations therein, we have to apparently reconsider the veracity of the said phrase. The point, in our view, is laid in our contemplation of the institution of damages as a remedy for breach which lead us to go beyond the restitution of the aggrieved party’s former status. This is, indeed, the role of economic notions in modern world which enables the similar construes.
Methodology:
During this article and having studied the methods of evaluating the damages caused by non-performance of the obligations in English legal system (as well as exploring the latest studies in this field) and also a number of most reputable international legal instruments such as United Nations Convention on International Sale of Goods, Undroit Principles of International Commercial Contracts, Principles of European Contract Law and Draft Common Frame of Reference, we tried to support a construe under Iranian law which goes beyond the current contemplations regarding the damages.
Results & Discussion:
United Nations Convention on International Sale of Goods (“CISG”), having considered the methods for valuation of damages in Articles 75 and 76, has also invalidates both the subjective and objective tests in claiming the damages. In other words, the modern world necessitates to even remove the subjective test in the course of appraisal of damages (as referred in Article 76 of CISG). In addition, other major international instruments have almost paved the same path and approved the methods of “buying the goods in replacement” and “current price of the goods”. This point reveals when we come up with Article 7.4.13 of the Undroit Principles of International Commercial Contracts (“Unidroit”) and compare the same with Article 230 of IRI Civil Code. Thus, the institution of damages is mainly designed to cover the expectations of the parties before entering into a contract and we can, consequently, come to conclusion that “Restitution Basis”, as a minimal construe of the same, shall stand in exterior of the territory of damages.
Analyzing the economic outcomes of “Restitution”, “Expectation” and “Reliance” methods as well as more recent theories such as “Incomplete Contracts” and “Efficient Breach” (besides the studies based on economic analysis of law during the years of 20th century), with due regard to the necessities of the local market and during the short term at least, we can rely on a justifiable basis like “Expectation”.
Conclusions & Suggestions:
Taking the foregoing into account, we have to remark on a few points as follows:
1) The legislator’s approach to the institution of damages shall be varied at the very first stage so as the efficiency of the contractual liability system be improved (in terms of legal view point and more particularly in terms of economic point of view). Providing a set of certain and practical methods for valuation of damages, empowers the parties to measure the risks (and the scope thereof) and cover the same through the means such as insurance. Accordingly, the proposed techniques by the international instruments are so close to our dominant notions under Iranian (and Fiqhi) framework. Having done the same, the given approach in our system will become more consistent with the prevailing methods in Common Law (realization of “Expectation Basis” as the pioneer ways suggested by the classic division of Fuller and Perdue).
2) Concentration on the criminal feature of the liquidated damages assists us to guide the appetite of the legal system to Expectation and Reliance Basis as the real outcomes of the concept of damages while the Restitution Basis may be analyzed within the area of termination and the consequences thereof.
3) Insofar as we know, the law on adjustment of the contractual terms has a major impact on modern theories raised in this respect. However, even if the re-negotiation of the said terms enables the parties to achieve a sort of post efficiency, this kind of adjustment would certainly damage the former distribution of the contractual risks as considered by the parties in prior. So, in order to design an efficient scheme for the parties, we have to consider (inasmuch as viable) the nature of the given risks and the manner to cover the same. By the way, comparing the effects of such studies with the key notions of the Iranian legal system, the economic impacts of the relevant methods on a progressive economy such as Iran shall not be ignored. That is the reason we propose not to copy the ultra-modern theories such as “Incomplete Contracts” and “Efficient Breach” and focus on the “Expectation Basis”.
Third party financial support approach in international investment arbitration
Volume 29, Issue 21, August 2022, Pages 341-379
https://doi.org/10.22067/economlaw.2022.74113.1119
Seyed Sadegh Ebrahimi, Peyman Bolori, Mohammad Ali Solhchi, Mohammad Bagher Ghorbanvand
Abstract Arbitration for international investment comes at a high cost to both the investor and the government in question. One of the new phenomena in international investment arbitration is the financing of litigation by a third party investor. This investor is not interested in the issue of arbitration, but enters it with the hope that it will be profitable from resolving the dispute. International arbitrators have, in principle, no jurisdiction to review a third-party investment agreement because their jurisdiction is limited to litigation between the foreign investor and the host government. The investment agreement, therefore, has nothing to do with the legal relationship between the foreign investor and the host government. It will also point out that the existence of an investment agreement is subject to transparency rules to ensure that the principle of equality is respected, and that a third-party investment investor is an investor in financial claims and claims that acts before a court or arbitral tribunal. With the participation of a third party investment investor, the plaintiff (claimant) may use the necessary resources and intervene in the litigation or arbitration. Instead, the third-party investor is promised a portion of the profits if the lawsuit is successful. If the lawsuit is unsuccessful, the third-party investment investor will bear the costs of participating in the lawsuit or arbitration instead of the plaintiff.
The Maximum Amount of Penalty Clause in Monetary Obligations with a Critical Approach to the Supreme Court's Unified Judicial Precedent No. 805
Volume 29, Issue 22, February 2023, Pages 348-321
https://doi.org/10.22067/economlaw.2022.73972.1114
Rasool Bahrampoori, Javad Khodadadi
Abstract Validity of penalty clause in monetary obligations has always been a controversial issue in the Iranian legal system. Due to the exposure of institutions such as the Constitutional Council and the Expediency Discernment Council to the damage of late payment, despite the adoption of laws such as the Code of Civil Procedure this question still remains in the Iranian legal system and it is asked the parties can claim a sum in excess of the annual rate of the Central Bank as a fixed sum, based on the contractual terms? General Assembly of the Supreme Court's Unified Judicial Precedent No. 805 has considered the permission of this matter subject to its non-contradiction with the imperative laws and regulations and the present study with an analytical-descriptive method in order to answer above question, by examining evolutions regarding the damages of late payment in the Iranian legal system, state three jurisprudential, legal and economic analyzes and it has proved that accepting the validity of any amount of contractual obligation in monetary obligations can't be deduced not only from the text of the relevant laws and regulations but in addition to conflict with the law, has many adverse economic effects and exposes the agreement to the suspicion of usury.
Legal and economic analysis of surface runoff losses and how to compensate
Volume 29, Issue 21, August 2022, Pages 380-422
https://doi.org/10.22067/economlaw.2022.72149.1082
Ali Roohizadeh
Abstract Nowadays surface runoff pollution as a crisis of human societies, has forced most countries to seek legal solutions to solve this phenomenon, the most important of which is the establishment of civil liability in this area. Although, according to economic analysis, compensation can not have much effect on optimal deterrence, nevertheless, its effect on reducing water pollution can not be denied.
This study, after a comprehensive review of available sources and then analyzing the findings, has concluded that the mere existence of pollution causes harm, so it is sufficient to determine the causality relationship between the pollution and its actor in order to establish civil liability; In addition, the government can be held liable for damages, both in terms of supervision and ownership, and by providing a broad interpretation of the concept of "beneficiary", it can be said that NGOs are considered "beneficiaries" in making such claims and assuming victory in litigation, compensation can be used for sustainable development.
Finally, according to the model of sustainable development in the economy, the production of goods is not only a subordinate of labor and capital, but must also be considered in the production process, materials and environmental goods such as water. Therefore, from the perspective of environmental economics, water pollution is considered as a cost of production or consumption, and the higher this cost, the optimal production and economic growth will not be a subordinate of sustainable development.
Implications of rational choice theory in judges' decisions
Volume 29, Issue 22, February 2023, Pages 380-349
https://doi.org/10.22067/economlaw.2023.76637.1180
zahra sakiani, mojtaba ghasemi
Abstract A set of factors that affect Judicial behavior have been studied from the perspective of various sciences such as economics. Economics offers a specific way of delving into different subjects. Regarding the concepts of rational choice theory in economics such as its definitional meaning (making proportional tools and goals), maximizing expected utility, and maximizing wealth, this paper seeks to show what factors can influence judicial decisions and behaviors. It seems that recognizing the factors influencing the behavior of judges by policymakers and paying attention to them in policy-making can increasingly affect the quality and quantity of verdicts reached by judges and can lead to better allocation of financial resources in the judiciary system. The finding results based on library resources and descriptive-analytical methods show that hiring more judges to increase court outputs is not always an optimal solution. Even in some cases, an increase in judges' productivity allowances can provide enough external incentive to improve the quality and quantity of their verdicts.
Status of Cryptocurrencies in International Monetary and Financial Law
Volume 29, Issue 22, February 2023, Pages 411-381
https://doi.org/10.22067/economlaw.2023.79170.1230
Seyed Yaser Ziaee, Masoomeh Sadat Hoseini
Abstract Cryptocurrencies is a class of digital asset that is controlled using cryptographic algorithms and often works in a decentralized manner. Some experts believe that cryptocurrencies could be the future currency or international money. Therefore, cryptocurrencies and related technology might disrupt many things, including finance and law. Fiat currencies derive their authority from the government or monetary authorities. For example, the Federal Reserve back-stops each dollar bill. However, Cryptocurrencies are not backed by any public or private entities. Therefore, it has been difficult to make a case for their legal status in different financial jurisdictions throughout the world. In order to determine the positions, capacities, and challenges of cryptocurrencies in international monetary and financial law, it is necessary to first analyze the status of cryptocurrencies as money and then examine the position of cryptocurrencies in the International Monetary Fund as well as some other international financial organizations. Monetary and financial organizations have had different positions towards cryptocurrencies. The International Monetary Fund has done little more than encouraging the use of government cryptocurrencies. The position of international financial institutions has also been different in this regard: from the pessimistic approach of the Bank of International Settlements and the European Central Bank to the organizing approach of the Financial Action Task Force, as well as the passive approach of the World Bank Group. It seems that in order to use the benefits of cryptocurrencies (such as blockchain technology in international transactions) and avoid the problems caused by them (such as currency instability and financial crimes), it is necessary to complete and strengthen the international monetary and financial law system in this regard.
Assessing the financing of the driver compensation system in the light of the Compulsory Insurance Law approved in 2016
Volume 29, Issue 21, August 2022, Pages 423-448
https://doi.org/10.22067/economlaw.2022.74059.1116
Hamid Afkar
Abstract Objective: The foundation of the driver compensation system has been established in legal systems based on logical, social and economic interests. On the other hand, paying attention to the legal security and financial resources of the insurer and the bodily injury indemnity fund shakes the foundations of the idea of absolute protection of the victims of traffic accidents. Exaggeration in identifying the responsibility of these two social institutions in relation to compensating the driver who caused the accident will weaken the efficiency of the insurance industry and reduce public resources. Identifying the liability of the insurer and the bodily injury indemnity fund in the driver compensation system for damages before and after the adoption of the new insurance law requires reviewing the law, legal and economic foundations in order to achieve the goal of protecting the victims of traffic accidents and taking into account the social and financial interests of the insurer and the fund, to provide an effective interpretation of the idea of compensating the driver who caused the accident.
Methodology: The method used in this research is descriptive-analytical.
Findings: Law and legal justifications in the new insurance law indicate the obligation of the insurer and the insured to conclude a driver accident insurance contract. Although driver accident insurance is independent of third party insurance, the violation of the legal duty in issuing driver accident insurance by the insurer imposes a mandatory imposition of legal obligations on the insurer. Utilizing the foundations of the social welfare system or considering the fault of society as the broadest organization, justifies the responsibility of the government and society to the driver who caused the accident without insurance, and the bodily injury indemnity fund as an alternative to insurance is the most effective source of compensation. It does not make sense to extend the liability of the fund and the insurer to the uninsured driver for damages before the adoption of the new insurance law, and the resources of these two institutions are severely lacking.
Conclusion: Law and legal basis justifying the liability of the insurer and the fund According to the new law, does not include the past bodily injuries of the driver who does not have accident insurance and in addition, the lack of economic efficiency and rational justification excludes the insurer and the fund from the resources of the driver compensation system causing the accident. Keywords: The driver who caused the accident, Driver Accident Insurance, Insurer, Bodily injury indemnity fund.
