A Critical Analysis of the Legislative Discourse on Green Taxation in Iran, Focusing on the Requirements of the Aarhus Convention (From Fragmented Legislation to Participatory Regulation)
Volume 33, Issue 29, September 2026, Pages 155-181
https://doi.org/10.22067/economlaw.2026.97938.1523
Hadi Salehi, Mojtaba Vaezie, Tahereh Hazbeh
Abstract In contemporary societies, public decision-making has been shaped by new mechanisms and strategies. The environmental domain has not remained unaffected by this transformation and, through the emergence of green-oriented instruments and modern technologies, has entered a new stage of public governance. Within this context, green taxation—known as Pigouvian taxation aimed at internalizing negative externalities—goes beyond a mere fiscal instrument and serves as a redefinition of the relationship between the state and citizens in environmental protection. However, the effective realization of this policy is hardly possible without a transparent and equitable framework; otherwise, it may result in social discrimination, neglect of public rights, and a lack of accountability. The Aarhus Convention, as one of the most significant international instruments, provides a framework for transparency, accountability, and public participation in environmental governance, thereby enhancing citizens’ environmental rights and strengthening public oversight over environmental policymaking.
As a country heavily dependent on fossil fuels, Iran faces severe challenges such as air pollution, water scarcity, and climate change. Under such circumstances, the proper implementation of fiscal policies can serve as a tool to reduce inefficient energy consumption, mitigate pollution, and promote sustainable economic development. The aim of this study is to provide a legal analysis of the discursive and regulatory structures related to green taxation in Iran, with reference to the key principles of the Aarhus Convention, and to propose recommendations for strengthening the legal legitimacy of this instrument in the national legislative system. This involves a shift from the current model of “fragmented legislation and administrative enforcement” toward “participatory regulation” in green policymaking.
The key findings indicate that: (i) Iranian law lacks a unified definition of “green tax,” addressing it instead through fragmented instruments such as levies, penalties, and revenues—an ambiguity that prevents clear legal commitments to pollution reduction and earmarking revenues for environmental purposes. (ii) Green taxation in Iran significantly diverges from the Aarhus Convention’s standards of democratic and fair environmental governance: on the one hand, restrictions imposed under the label of “confidentiality” and weaknesses in data disclosure undermine the right of free access to environmental information; on the other hand, there is no formal and transparent mechanism for citizen or civil society (NGO) participation in legislative processes, contrary to the Aarhus emphasis on public involvement prior to adopting environmentally significant decisions. (iii) Whereas the Aarhus Convention guarantees access to justice for individuals and NGOs, in Iran the absence of clear standing for organizations or individuals to bring claims, and the lack of mechanisms to demand urgency in suspending environmentally harmful decisions, create insufficient legal effectiveness.
This descriptive-analytical study shows that although Iran possesses certain initial legal infrastructures, the absence of a clear legal status, institutional framework, and operational procedures prevents green taxation from aligning with the Aarhus Convention’s requirements. By implementing targeted legal reforms and strengthening mechanisms of participation and transparency, green taxation can be effectively and legitimately integrated into the country’s fiscal and environmental governance system
Quantitative Restrictions on the Principle of Freedom of Trade in the light of the Laws and Verdicts of the General Assembly of the Administrative Justice Court
Volume 29, Issue 22, February 2023, Pages 111-71
https://doi.org/10.22067/economlaw.2023.76924.1182
Zahra Alborzi, Mohammad Emami, Seyed Mojtaba Vaezi
Abstract Today, the concept of economic freedom as one of the necessary conditions for achieving sustainable growth and development has particular importance, so understanding the concept and components of the subject, as well as the limitations and obstacles imposed on it, are essential for any legal system to achieve economic growth and prosperity by reducing or eliminating barriers. Therefore, in the present article, the quantitative limitations of the principle of freedom of trade as one of the components of economic freedom are explained by descriptive-analytical method, and the approach of the Iranian legal system was examined through scrutiny of laws, regulations and annulments of the General Assembly. The result is that the Constitution and related ordinary laws, such as the Article 44 General Policy Implementation Law, the Development Plan Law, the Export and Import Law, and the Customs Law, have been legislated in order to support the development of foreign trade, facilitate the processes of the licenses, reduced customs formalities and also the removal of non-tariff barriers. Contrary to the legislative approach, the executive sometimes creates or expands trade restrictions and prohibitions through regulation, but The Administrative Justice Court, as the body that oversees government approvals, relies on the rule of law, often with a narrow interpretation of the legal restrictions and citing to general legal principles such as the acquired right have protected the freedoms of individuals.
