Author = bagheri, mahmood

Economic Analysis of Tax and Subsidy Policies and Regulations in Iranian Financial Markets with a Distributive Justice Approach Based on Kaldor–Hicks Efficiency Theory

Volume 29, Issue 22, February 2023, Pages 142-113

https://doi.org/10.22067/economlaw.2023.74587.1132

Mahmood Bagheri, Saeed Mohammadi Bidhendi

Abstract It is assumed that financial markets by utilising private law instruments operate in a way which lead to equilibrium and efficiency based on distributive justice. However, in case financial markets deviate from this equilibrium and efficiency, there is a need to provide and implement economic law remedial solutions which, includes the utilisation of tax-subsidy policies that bring in favorable distributive outcomes. The present study uses library resources and descriptive analytical approach to analyze important tax-subsidy interventions in Iranian financial markets, explain appropriate normative framework for tax-subsidy intervention in financial markets and examine compliance of tax-subsidy interventions in Iranian financial markets with this normative framework. The authors believe that the most appropriate way to restore the efficiency and equilibrium of financial markets is to apply those tax-subsidy policies and regulations that are based on the Kaldor-Hicks formula of distributive justice; Derived from economic analysis of law. These interventions are designed in a way that if in short-term they bring in adverse effects for some groups, these groups will be compensated by the effect of wealth maximization in the long run.
 

PhD Student in Private Law. University of Judicial Sciences and Administrative Services

Volume 27, Issue 18, June 2021, Pages 103-128

https://doi.org/10.22067/lowecon.2021.39390

Fatemeh Kiaee, Hassan Rahpeik, mahmood bagheri

Abstract  
Extended Abstract
Introduction
Applying general bankruptcy rules to banks might cause many legal problems. Distinct characteristics of banks and their important role in the financial system makes many countries use the recovery institution in order to prevent the banks’ bankruptcy. The assessment of Iran regulations shows that any comprehensive laws of recovery have not ever legislated, hence it seems necessary to enact efficient laws in this regard. Due to the distinct social, economic, political, and legal characteristics of countries, it is not possible to provide a consistent model for recovery regulation in all countries. Moreover, translating and copying from other countries should not be utilized to formulate recovery regulations. Therefore, adoption of recovery institutions requires it to be completely analyzed and investigated.
Theoretical frame work
This study on the one hand explains the concept of recovery and introduce the most common methods of recovery. On the other hand, it analyses the Iranian regulations in the field of bank recovery and reviews the practical recovery examples in Iran and evaluates their efficiency. Finally, by understanding the legal nature of each recovery method, the one with correct legal basis according to Iranian law (i.e. appropriate to be adopted in Iran) is determined. A legal model that is consistent with the legal principles of Iran is consequently proposed
 
 
Methodology
This study attempts to answer the main questions of this research based on the analysis of the legal nature of the recovery. It investigates the possibility of adopting the recovery models in Iran by criticizing and comparing various statutes, regulations, and legal doctrines of different countries.
Results & Discussion
Bankruptcy is a judicial process that only considers the rights of creditors neglecting public benefit. Recovery, on the other hand, is an administrative process with the aim of allowing bank depositors to continue to meet their liquidity needs by accessing banking services. In addition, in this process, the bank's assets are managed in such a way that the value of the insolvent bank is maintained. In this paper, three widely used methods of bank recovery, which are mergers, purchase and assumption, and payments through the Deposit Guarantee are examined. Regarding the difference between the merger method and the purchase and assumption method, it should be noted that the latter involves the purchase of the insolvent bank’s assets and the acceptance of its liabilities, while in the former, the insolvent bank shares are sold and solvent Bank becomes the deputy director of the insolvent bank.  In addition, in the purchase and assumption method the legal personality of the insolvent bank does not disappear, but in the merger model, the legal personality of the insolvent bank disappears by merging with the solvent bank. On the other hand, the difference between the payments through the Deposit Guarantee Fund and the merger model is that the assignment of the bank commitment to the fund does not remove the contractual liability from the bank. This fact is in contrast to the merger method, which is based on the transfer of the contract. In the Deposit Guarantee Fund, the insolvent bank is still recognized as a party to the contract with depositors. However, in the merger method, the legal personality of the insolvent bank is completely reserved and the solvent Bank becomes its deputy. 
Conclusions & Suggestions
In this paper a recovery model consistent with the legal principles of Iran is proposed. It is shown that the preparation of the Bank Recovery Law should not be merely an imitation and requires an analysis of the legal nature of recovery methods. The proposed model for Iran, through the mergers as well as purchase and assumption methods, is a bilateral legal act (contract). Similar to the legal systems of some other countries, namely, US, Switzerland and Canada, the permission of debtors and creditors of the bank is not part of the basic structure of the proposed recovery model. However, the imposition of this plan on creditors can only take place if the proposed recovery plan is perfectly appropriate and in the interests of the creditors. The proposed legal model, if payment is made through the Deposit Guarantee Fund, is inherently a contract that is made solely by the will of the Deposit Guarantee Fund. Thus, there is no need for the permission of the depositors and the insolvent bank, because the bank's permission is not a condition for its validity and only deprives the fund of referring to it. In the model, the central bank or deposit guarantee fund is considered as a supervisory authority over the banking system. This authority, based on the estimated costs and conditions of the insolvent bank, takes into account the order of priority i.e. mergers, purchase and assumption, and payments through the Deposit Guarantee Fund. It then applies the proposed model to prevent the bank from going bankrupt. The adoption of an inconsistent law of recovery from other countries, in addition to its social, economic and political effects, could confuse and frustrate the legal system. Therefore, the development of efficient regulations in accordance with the nature of the recovery methods based on the proposed approach is of great importance in the Iranian legal system. 
 

Hisba as a Foundation of Islamic Economic Law: Regulation of Competition in Competition and non-Competition Markets

Volume 20, Issue 4, October 2013

https://doi.org/10.22067/le.v20i4.39698

Mahmood Bagheri, Mohammad Sadeghi

Abstract Hisba is a regulatory regime in Islamic law which could be a base for Islamic economic regulation but has been neglected for centuries. The protection of integrity of the market and competition is a prominent economic and legal objective in modern economies. However, the focus in the Islamic law has been on the bipolar relations among the individuals in the form of law of contract or law of tort. As such there has been little attention towards Hisba which is a nongovernmental public institution for regulation of market. The current paper is seeking to elaborate the role of this institutions in terms of maintaining competition in the market on the basis of Islamic law. This paper shall partly introduce the Hisba and its potentials as a regulatory institutions for regulating market in general and shall then examine the use of this institution to build up a legal regime based on Islamic law and principles for regulation both contestable markets (competition law) and regulating non contestable markets (sector regulation) in the Islamic countries.